Take note of these 2011 Boy Scout requirement changes

BSArequirements2011 Any great organization constantly tweaks and adapts its requirements to better reach its members, and the Boy Scouts of America is no exception.

To that end, the BSA announced this week which requirements will change in 2011.

One big item is actually more of a clarification than a complete change. It affects the requirements for the Eagle Scout rank. Here's what it says:

"The 2009 printing of the Boy Scout Handbook inadvertently included bugler as a position of responsibility under Eagle Scout requirement 4; it is not. … The corrected Eagle Scout requirement 4 will appear in the next printing of the Boy Scout Handbook."

That paragraph is consistent with an Ask the Expert question we fielded back in March of 2010. As we told you then, Bugler is not an official position of responsibility for Eagle Scout, but it is O.K. to use with Life or Star ranks.

Another change affects requirement 6 of the Life rank. Add subpoint G as a seventh option for Scouts teaching the EDGE method to another Scout. The new option reads: "Three requirements from one of the Eagle-required merit badges, as approved by your unit leader."

The other 2011 requirement changes affect merit badges: 

  • Requirements for Astronomy, Horsemanship, and Nuclear Science merit badges have been revised. (Click each link for the new requirements)
  • Minor updates will be made to the requirements for Archery and Sports merit badges. (Click each link to see the revisions)
  • Three new merit badges that were added in 2010 will be added to the 2011 Boy Scout Requirements Book: Geocaching, Inventing, and Scouting Heritage.

Keep in mind, though, that a Scout who has started working on a merit badge when a new pamphlet or requirements come out may continue working from the original requirements. He need not start the merit badge over.

We'll give you the specific requirement changes for those merit badges as soon as we have them, so stay tuned.

4 thoughts on “Take note of these 2011 Boy Scout requirement changes

  1. What happened to the changes to Music merit badge? I realize Bugling will not be dropped as a merit badge, but there were some other requirements that appeared to change in the Music pamphlet that was issued during 2010.

  2. Pingback: Boy Scout Advancement Changes – Effective Jan 1, 2011 | Troop 709 | Flower Mound, TX

  3. This is not good at all…. Prior to the “reporting ” that [ 2009 printing of the Boy Scout Handbook inadvertently included bugler as a position of responsibility under Eagle Scout requirement 4 ] ….. if you look at prior handbooks you find that the Positions of Responsibility (POR’s) point to a page that contains a photo of all the POR’s …which included Bugler,,,,and then if you READ the text listing the positions you find that ONE of the positions in the picture page is listed twice and bugler is omitted…. the obvious conclusion was always that the duplication was the error and the bugler was simply the one position that should have been in the text instead of the duplicated one….since there were NO Other POR’s !!!

    Now they have added some new ones…. that do count,,, (like webmaster) and specified bugler does not…. such an error is modern oversight and revisionism of the worst kind.! The traditional bugler was a serious POR that demanded a lot of work and responsibility …. does your troop have a Flag corps, does the bugler play at all camp outs, flag ceremony, and call assembly at camp??/…. if not, WHY NOT ?
    The duty of the sponsor of the POR must be to enforce the responsibility to PLAY. Webmaster… HA, ,,,, shows how far behind the times the Advancement Board is in terms of technology….a couple years ago the webmaster had to know how to write code…. now its a WYSIWYG automated programs…..so its too easy to be a POR !!
    But them it will take National another 10 years to catch on to that !!

Join the conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s